Installing Hardwood Over Existing Flooring- One Year Review: Success or Fail?

Thinking about installing hardwood over existing flooring? You’re not alone—Installing Hardwood Over Existing Flooring- One Year Review can give you the insights you need.
Many homeowners consider this option for a stylish upgrade without the hassle of removing old floors. But how does it hold up over time?
In this blog post, we’ll share our one-year review of installing hardwood over existing flooring. We’ll discuss the pros and cons, the process, and what you need to know.
We aim to help you make an informed decision. Hardwood floors can transform your space, but you want to ensure it’s a smart investment. Stay with us as we dive into our experience, offering insights and tips from the past year. Let’s see if this flooring choice stands the test of time.
Preparation Process
Installing hardwood over existing flooring requires careful preparation. A well-executed preparation process ensures the new floor is durable and looks stunning. Let’s dive into the details.
Materials Needed
Before starting, gather the necessary materials. Here is a list of what you need:
- Hardwood planks – Choose high-quality planks for a long-lasting floor.
- Underlayment – Provides a smooth base and reduces noise.
- Adhesive – Use a strong adhesive to secure the planks.
- Wood filler – Fill gaps and cracks for a seamless finish.
- Sealant – Protects the wood and enhances its appearance.
Tools Required
Having the right tools makes the installation process smoother. Ensure you have the following tools:
- Measuring tape – For accurate measurements.
- Utility knife – To cut underlayment and other materials.
- Hammer and nails – For securing the planks.
- Nail gun – Speeds up the nailing process.
- Rubber mallet – For gently tapping planks into place.
- Level – Ensures the floor is even.
- Vacuum cleaner – Keeps the area clean and dust-free.
A well-prepared floor creates a solid foundation for your new hardwood. Taking the time to gather all materials and tools will make the installation process efficient and enjoyable.
Installation Steps
Installing hardwood over existing flooring can be a rewarding project. This section covers the steps you need to follow. Proper preparation and careful execution ensure a smooth and durable finish.
Removing Old Flooring
First, remove any old flooring. Start by clearing the room of all furniture and items. Next, use a crowbar or similar tool to pry up the old flooring. Be gentle to avoid damaging the subfloor.
Dispose of the old flooring material responsibly. Sweep the area clean. Make sure the subfloor is even and free of debris. Check for any nails or staples and remove them.
If the subfloor has any damage, repair it. Use a leveling compound to fill in low spots. Allow it to dry completely before proceeding.
Laying The Hardwood
Start by laying a moisture barrier over the subfloor. This prevents moisture from damaging the hardwood. Next, acclimate the hardwood planks in the room for at least 48 hours. This helps the wood adjust to the room’s humidity and temperature.
Begin laying the planks along the longest wall. Use spacers to maintain a small gap between the planks and the wall. This allows for natural expansion. Secure the planks using nails or adhesive, depending on the type of hardwood.
Continue laying the planks row by row. Stagger the end joints for a natural look. Use a tapping block to fit the planks tightly together. Cut the final pieces to fit using a saw. Remove the spacers and install the baseboards to cover the gaps.
Your new hardwood floor is now installed. Enjoy the beauty and warmth it brings to your home.
Challenges Encountered
Installing hardwood over existing flooring can be quite a journey. The process is not without its challenges. Here are some of the issues we faced during the installation, and how they affected us over the past year.
Surface Issues
One of the first challenges was dealing with the existing flooring’s surface. The old floor was uneven in many places. These uneven spots made it hard to lay the new hardwood smoothly.
We had to sand down the high spots and fill in the low spots. This process was time-consuming and messy. Despite our best efforts, some areas are still not perfectly flat. This has led to a few creaky spots in the new floor.
Alignment Problems
Aligning the new hardwood with the existing floor presented another set of challenges. The old floor was not perfectly square with the walls. This made it tricky to get the new boards lined up correctly.
We used spacers and chalk lines to help guide us. Still, some boards ended up slightly misaligned. This misalignment is noticeable in a few places. It has not affected the floor’s functionality, but it is not visually perfect.
Overall, these challenges taught us a lot about the importance of preparation. Proper surface leveling and careful alignment are key to a successful hardwood installation. Despite the issues, we are still pleased with our new floor. It has added warmth and beauty to our home.

Credit: www.reddit.com
Post-installation Observations
A year has passed since we installed hardwood over our existing flooring. We have made several observations during this period. These insights will help you understand what to expect and how to handle any issues that arise.
Immediate Impressions
The first thing we noticed was the beauty of the new hardwood. It transformed the look of our space. The sleek, natural finish added warmth and elegance. Walking on the new floor felt solid and satisfying. The difference was immediately apparent.
Initial Adjustments
In the first few weeks, we had to make some minor adjustments. We noticed small gaps between some of the planks. This was due to the wood settling and adjusting to the room’s humidity. To fix this, we used a wood filler that matched the floor color.
We also found that some furniture needed felt pads. This protected the new floor from scratches. Adding area rugs in high-traffic areas helped too. These small steps ensured that the hardwood looked great and stayed in good condition.

Credit: designingvibes.com
Performance After One Year
Installing hardwood over existing flooring can be a practical solution. But how does it hold up over time? Here’s a detailed review of the performance after one year. We will examine the durability and appearance of the hardwood flooring.
Durability
The hardwood has shown remarkable durability after one year. Daily wear and tear have had minimal impact. The surface remains mostly scratch-free. Heavy furniture has not caused any dents.
A few high-traffic areas have minor scuffs. They are barely noticeable. Regular cleaning and maintenance help preserve the condition. Overall, the floor has maintained its sturdiness and reliability.
Appearance
The appearance of the hardwood floor is still impressive. The color and finish remain intact. The natural wood grain looks as beautiful as day one.
There is no sign of fading or discoloration. Even in sunlight-exposed areas. Regular cleaning keeps the floor looking fresh and new. The hardwood adds a warm and elegant touch to the home.
Here is a simple table summarizing the observations:
Aspect | Observation |
---|---|
Durability | Minimal scratches, no dents, high sturdiness |
Appearance | Color and finish intact, no fading |
The hardwood floor has proven to be a worthwhile investment. Its durability and appearance remain strong after one year.
Maintenance Insights
Installing hardwood over existing flooring offers a fresh, elegant look. But, how has it held up after one year? This section delves into the maintenance aspects. We will share insights on cleaning routines and repair needs for your new hardwood floor.
Cleaning Routine
Keeping your new hardwood floor clean is simple. Daily sweeping is necessary to avoid dust buildup. Use a soft-bristle broom to prevent scratches.
For deeper cleaning, a weekly mop with a damp cloth is ideal. Avoid using too much water as it can damage the wood. A mixture of water and a few drops of gentle wood cleaner works best.
Consider using rugs in high-traffic areas. This protects the floor and reduces the frequency of cleaning. Remember to shake out and wash the rugs regularly.
Repair Needs
Hardwood is durable, but occasional repairs might be needed. Small scratches and dents can appear over time. These can often be fixed with a wood filler.
Larger issues, like deep gouges or warping, might require professional help. Keep an eye out for signs of water damage. Fix leaks and spills quickly to prevent long-term damage.
Regular maintenance can extend the life of your floor. Inspect your flooring every few months. Look for any changes and address them promptly.
Final Thoughts
One year later, the hardwood over existing flooring remains sturdy and beautiful. The installation process proved successful and durable. This method offers an efficient way to upgrade home flooring.
As we reach the end of our one-year review, it’s important to reflect on the installation of hardwood over existing flooring. This project can transform the look of your home. But it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons before starting.
Pros And Cons
There are many benefits to installing hardwood over existing flooring. Firstly, it saves time and effort. You don’t need to remove the old floor. This can be a major advantage. Secondly, it adds a layer of insulation. This can help in maintaining the temperature of your home. Thirdly, the look and feel of hardwood are unmatched. It adds elegance and value to your home.
On the downside, there are some potential issues. The existing floor must be in good condition. Otherwise, you risk uneven surfaces. Also, it can raise the height of your floor. This might affect doors and appliances. Lastly, it can be a bit expensive. Quality hardwood and installation come with a price.
Recommendations
If you decide to go ahead, here are a few recommendations. First, ensure your existing floor is level and stable. This is crucial for a smooth installation. Next, choose quality hardwood. Good materials make a big difference. They last longer and look better.
Also, consider professional installation. While DIY might save money, professionals ensure a perfect finish. Finally, maintain your new floor well. Regular cleaning and care can extend its lifespan. This investment can pay off for years to come.
In summary, installing hardwood over existing flooring can be a great choice. Just make sure to consider all factors. With the right approach, your home can look amazing.

Credit: honeybuilthome.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Can You Install Hardwood Over Existing Flooring?
Yes, you can install hardwood over existing flooring. Ensure the existing floor is level, clean, and secure before installation.
How Long Does It Take To Install Hardwood?
The installation process usually takes 1-3 days. This depends on the room size and floor condition.
What Are The Benefits Of Hardwood Over Existing Flooring?
Hardwood adds value, durability, and aesthetic appeal. It also eliminates the need for floor removal.
Does Hardwood Installation Damage Existing Flooring?
Proper installation should not damage existing flooring. Ensure professionals handle the process to avoid any issues.
Conclusion
The hardwood installation over existing flooring has been a success. One year later, the floors remain beautiful and durable. Daily use has shown minimal wear and tear. Maintenance is simple and quick. Overall, this decision has proven wise. The new look has brightened the home.
Guests often compliment the elegant finish. Considering hardwood? It’s worth it. Quality and appearance make it a great choice. Enjoy the comfort and style it brings.